What the Palm Prē is missing

This weekend I actually stood in line and bought a Palm Pre.

Palm Pre

Palm Pre

I know. I’ve never stood in line early in the morning on a release day for any piece of technology before, but my old phone had about 15 minutes of talk time left and it was time to buy a replacement before I go on vacation to NYC and Philly this week.

The Pre has a great interface. You can read more about all of the nifty features on other sites. I find it easier to use than an iPhone, but I tend to be generally be incompetent with Apple products for whatever reason. So far, Sprint has been great and I’ve had no issues with coverage or dropped calls. I’m glad to no longer be sharing the same network with iPhone users. Ever since the day the iPhone 3G was released, ATT’s network seemed significantly more unreliable to me.

There have been some annoyances with WebOS, though. I think it is worth publishing lacking features and gripes so that people who are considering purchasing the phone can decide if it would be a deal breaker and also I hope that Palm may read this and fix the issues.

Messaging

Once you are in a thread/conversation view, there is no way to add more people on SMS. Say somebody sends me a text message “Ya’ll in for brunch today?”. Clearly, it was sent to more than me. I have a good idea who. I want to respond to more than the sender (SMS is very limited here, but I can guess who this person invited) and say “Yeah, how about that restaurant next to my place at 12:30”.  Unfortunately, from the thread view, I can’t just reply and add people. I basically want Google Wave here. Also, SMS sucks so I expect as more people move to smartish phones SMS as it stands will die when e-mail could be used instead. Not having the ability to reply-to-all will be SMS’s downfall.

Twitter does not integrate in to messaging, surprisingly. It is currently only available as a standalone 3rd party app. It would be nice to see tweets, replies, etc within the messenger so that you could quickly respond to a tweet via e-mail or sms. Imagine a conversation that could go like this:

Alex (Twitter): Heading down to Emo’s for a Foot Patrol concert. Let me know if you want to come, I’ll buy a ticket.

Me (SMS): Hey, sweet get me a ticket before they sell out. Can only afford $20

Alex (SMS): Cool man, see you there. Heading out now.

Alex (Twitter): Sorry everybody, show sold out while I was in line. Other ideas for tonight?

Me (Twitter): @Alex Oh that stinks. Emo’s sucks anyways. Who wants to go to Mohawk instead to see Spoon?

It could save Alex from having to duplicate a messages and allowing me to keep certain things private and send things for immediate SMS delivery as I see fit. Since I currently have to switch between twitter app and messenger now, the flow of conversation gets broken up. So much for synergy. I may have confused it a bit with Google Wave, but it seems like this isn’t a hard thing to implement.

*Update 6/9/2009*
There appears to be no quick way to forward a TEXT message. Copy/Paste may work.

*Update 4/2/2010*
This has actually been available since WebOS 1.3.5 which was released at the end of December, 2009. I’ve been using it quite frequently!

E-mail

E-mail can be made much better. There is no limited search functionality within e-mail. Even the J2ME Gmail client lets you search through your Gmail. I understand the limitations of searching large amounts of text on an embedded device – but this is after all WebOS – it should be doing the searching in the cloud and returning the results to me.

Also, I’m pretty sure it is connecting to Gmail through IMAP, which really limits the Gmail functionality. I can’t star, tag, or archive e-mails. I chose gmail for its rich feature set, not to have it treated like a standard imap account.  My usage model for finding e-mails has changed from organizing e-mails and remembering when they were sent to searching for emails by content. Hopefully they work closer with Google to integrate a more Gmail-native-like experience into the native e-mail client, and including the ability to search the e-mail subject/body through universal search.

*Update 10/3/2009*
WebOS 1.2.0 adds limited search functionality to the mail client. You can now search by subject, to, from, or CC fields – but not the full body of the text. This is certainly a great improvement, but not quite what I’m used to on Gmail yet.

I should also note that it is possible to star/unstar messages in the mail client by flagging them. I believe this feature has been available for a while. Deleting messages from the Pre actually archives them. Archived messages are also accessible.

*Update 4/2/2010*
I’ve found that like the inability to search through all of my gmail content – the fact that only 1 month worth of gmail is synced is often annoying. There are certainly times I want to reference an older e-mail. I’m not going to sync my entire history of gmail to my phone as I’m sure that would fill it up and slow it down immensely. To fill this need, I occasionally have to log into gmail with the web browser app. Again – this just doesn’t feel very cloud-based.

*Update*

It also turns out that I cannot connect to my work Exchange e-mail because “Error – The mail server requires security policies that are not supported”. This is a huge deal. I’m not sure if it is due to PIN authentication or what, but as far as I know, if an iPhone or windows mobile phone can work here just fine, so should my Pre.  Here is an interesting thread on the matter.

And here on Palm’s site

*Update 7/27/2009*
Exchange support has been updated in WebOS 1.1 and now works!

*Update 6/9/2009*
Last night I got an e-mail from a friend that I thought I’d try to reply to various paragraphs in-line. Unfortunately, the Pre doesn’t seem to indent the old message or change font color – nothing. So the text I was entering looked just like the text my friend had written. It seems there is no clear way to do in-line e-mail replies.

Contacts

Overall, the contacts program is nice. I have way more contacts now on my phone than ever before thanks to Facebook, gmail contacts. You’d think it would be a pain to have too many, but searching makes it nice. Unfortunately, it takes a bit of manual effort syncing profiles together where it can’t automatically figure out that, say, my only “John” contact is also “John Smith” on gmail and “John C Smith” in Facebook.

What would be really nice here is some kind of app that just made suggestions that you could approve/disapprove to link contacts together. Search for name overlap and ask me a simple “Same person? Yes/No” question for each to help speed up the synergizing.

Calendar

*Update 6/9/2009*
The calendar is very well done, and I love how it integrates with my Google calendar. The updating seems to take a bit of time, though. So don’t expect to put a reminder in your Google calendar through Google and expect your pre to remind you in 5 minutes. I don’t know how long it takes to sync if you don’t force it.

The calendar is nice in that you can overlay all of your calendars. However, this is actually quite a problem if, say, in your Google calendar account you have several friends’ calendars, events calendars, etc that you don’t want to follow. Same for holiday calendars, local events calendars, etc. I want to have the ability to be able to look at their calendars, but don’t want that to be the default as it gets incredibly cluttered. I can view just my own personal calendar, but not select a subset of calendars to view. Its either one single calendar or all calendars. The interface gives you a check mark next to what you’re viewing (check marks tend to imply you can select multiple), but you can’t select multiple things in the box. A solution could be to provide “views” or sets of calendars that you predefine. Or just let me check all that I want to view at a given time.

*Update 7/28/2009*
Synchronizing now occurs every 15 minutes from Google Calendar to the phone as of WebOS 1.0.3. This seems like a reasonable amount of time. One would hope that you can remember if you have a meeting in 15 minutes and not be dependent on getting a reminder 10 minutes after you created it in Google Cal.

Either the sub-calendar disable feature has been around all along and I missed it, or was introduced in WebOS 1.1. By clicking on the Google account under preferences, you can choose whether or not to display each of your “Other Calendars” under the “All Calendars” view. This is great – I can ignore my friends’ calendars and Brazilian holidays unless I really want to see what they’re up to. Now it actually looks like I have free time.

*Update 4/2/2010*
It is also possible to force a sync with the calendar to make sure that it is up to date. This is a rather nice feature – though I rarely have to use it.

Web Browser

Overall, quite nice with the exception of lack of Adobe flash. That is nothing new on any mobile platform.

Small gripes: I tried to open a pdf and it says “Cannot find an application which can open this file”. Which is false, there is a pdf viewer. I also can’t figure out a way to save files to my phone. I’ve tried double-tapping, long-tap, function+tap, etc and nothing worked.

Likewise, I haven’t found a way to open a link in a new “card”. There are times I want to leave one page open and have another one in a new window. Again, maybe the feature is there, but its difficult enough that I haven’t found it yet.

*Update 10/3/2009*
WebOS 1.2.0 Has added the feature to save files to the Pre, offers better support for opening of files in the correct applications, and allows you to open a link in a new card by holding a finger in the gesture area while clicking a link. Very nice!

Music Player

I haven’t used it too much, but it is very apparent that switching between tracks is disappointingly slow.

*Update 10/3/2009*
While most of my updates today are positive improvements that have been made, I feel the need to point out some additional issues with the music player:

You can’t create a playlist from the Pre itself. This is a pretty lacking feature if, say, you want to make a sweet party mix while at a party and let it play. You can do shuffle-All and start removing things, but you cannot add a bunch of bands to a playlist, or individual songs. Certainly iPhone wins here.

There is no progress bar that you can slide to skip to a desired part of a track.
*Update 4/2/2010* – This was actually introduced in one of the 1.3.x series, I believe. If you hold down on the progress bar, you get a slider. Nice!

There is no equalizer.

Applications

So far, its hard to say what kind of interfaces applications can have to each other, or what kind of overloading can be done. In Android, developers & users can replace features of the default system with their own. Like… get a new dialer or phonebook. It doesn’t feel like the Pre will support this extendability

The worst thing is Sprint’s NASCAR app. I have no desire to ever look at NASCAR. Ever. I don’t want it taking up valuable precious icon space. And yet, it seems I cannot easily remove Sprint NASCAR from my phone. Something tells me that most Pre users don’t want this app, yet Sprint shoves it down our throats. Garbage. I don’t mind if they put it on, but let me delete it. They aren’t advertising NASCAR by having this application, they’re creating more disdain towards it.

*Update 7/21/2009*
You can actually hide or remove/delete the NASCAR app with some rather hackish steps outlined here.

*Update 7/27/2009*
With the WebOS 1.1 Update, rather than making this app easy to remove, Palm went ahead and added yet ANOTHER non-removable program, this time NFL.  I’m sure a lot of people may like this app, but I could care less. Don’t force it on me. I removed it with the above step, again.

*Update 10/3/2009*
Although you can remove the pesky apps, it seems that every time you get a WebOS Update it goes ahead and re-installs these awful things.

Navigation and Maps

Google Maps isn’t as featured as my cheapo-phone’s J2ME version. Most importantly, it lacks public transportation directions. That is really nice when taking the bus/metro somewhere. This is going to be incredibly frustrating for my NYC trip coming up next week. Hopefully Google implements the public transit search feature soon, or public-transport city-dwellers aren’t going to be terribly happy with this limitation.

*Update 10/3/2009*
The Google Maps application was recently updated to include both walking and public transportation directions. This is most excellent and should open up the Pre to more urban environments like NYC, Chicago, Boston, Philly, etc. Previous searches are now stored for the session, but are not remembered the next time you open the app. There is still no ability to bookmark locations. Hopefully one day this will be tied to your Google account.

GPS Navigation software was pretty impressive. It even works nicely with Pandora, lowering the music volume to announce a voice direction. It makes me want to buy a new head unit for my car that supports Bluetooth.

I’d like to see more interaction between Google Maps and Sprint Navigation. Google is great for finding places in a map, satellite view, etc. But not good for turn-by-turn live directions. Let me click an address in gMaps (or contacts, browser, etc) and add an option to add it as a destination in Sprint Navigation.

*Update 7/28/2009*
I’ve noticed that Navigation kills my battery and heats up my phone more than any other app. Even with the phone plugged in to the car charger, the phone begins draining. This software is one power-hungry hippo. I’ve tried putting maps in 2D instead of 3D view, turning off the screen – nothing helps. Not terribly useful for long trips if its going to leave you with a dead phone.

Camera

The camera’s quality seems quite nice in daylight. The LED flash is handy, but seems to turn everybody yellowish jaundice tones. The color correction could certainly be improved in software when the flash is used.

There is little manual control over color balance, exposure, etc. It has no self-timer, either.

Worst feature is that it doesn’t preview the photo for a few seconds after taking a pic, which seems to confuse users.

The software feature set of the camera could greatly be improved.

The photo viewer also seems a tad slow at resolving photos. I doubt Palm is really using the graphics hardware to its full potential here, so here’s hoping for some improvements with upcoming OS updates.

*Update 7/27/09*
WebOS 1.1 update provides slightly faster previewing of photos, but is still noticeably slower than I’d hope for. Though there is still no immediate photo preview like you get on a digital camera, at least now there is an animation to indicate that a photo was just taken, which will hopefully not confuse users.

WiFi

Day one of trying to get the Pre working on a corporate wifi WPA2 Enterprise network is a failure. I’m not convinced that it is going to have the necessary proxy configurations, either. Hopefully they update this or there is no way that the Pre is going to be able to compete with iPhone, BlackBerry, and Symbian in the corporate world.

Hardware

These are things that aren’t going to change with a software update, but I can deal with.

Battery life isn’t spectacular. I think I’ll be charging the phone every night. Luckily, with microUSB charging I won’t have to buy 3 $30 charger accessories, just a cheap cable.

Headphone jack is at the top of the phone. I can’t complain much, since Palm was smart/kind enough to include a 3.5mm headphone jack. But, it would be much less in the way if it were placed on the bottom of the phone, and would be better for putting in your pocket that way.

Tiny keys. There is no way around this for the format of the phone unless they forced you to use it Rumor/Sidekick landscape mode. So far, I’m adapting and like it much better than both iPhone’s on-screen keyboard and certainly better than T9/multitouch.

The camera lens placement is too low, and I find that I’m always covering it with my finger when trying to take a pic. I guess I expect it to be at the top of the phone when its slid open, for some reason. But, this allows you to take pics with the keyboard closed.

Summary

All in all, the Palm Pre Has a lot of potential. I do enjoy the overall UI experience, and I hope that they continue to do updates to get rid of many of the quirks that I have outlined above. I’m sure I’ll find more irksome things to post here as time goes on, and I’ll be sure to update this as things are resolved.

Also, here is a forum of wishlist items for the Palm Pre.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “What the Palm Prē is missing

  1. Kevin says:

    Perfect, I have read a lot of great things about Pre so far that make it enticing to buy. I think I could live with most of these nuances, although I’m betting more will come out as you use it. I’ll keep an eye out for updates.

  2. derek says:

    Actually, I prefer the headphone jack @the bottom, as is the case for my current Sony Ericson. Why? Well, when I put the phone in my side pocket, it has the face inwards (to protect the screen) and top end facing down. When it rings and I have to take it out, it comes into my hand with the top facing upwards and the screen towards me. Obviously this configuration also allows the headphone jack to be easily connected and “stick out” of my pocket. Make sense?

  3. Ron says:

    I like this blog! I am a business user of the Pre and it is difficult to do without many of my familiar Blackberry features. Could you add them to your “missing features” list?

    1. I can’t save special characters in the phone field contacts, like commas for pause and #, for conference calls, etc. with my Blackberry, I can just auto dial all the way into a conference call.

    2. Calendar: I can’t click on any numbers, emails or web addresses in teh calendar. they aren’t hyperlinked. this is a basic feature of a PDA.

    3. copy/paste is terrible. so hard to pin point where you start copy and finish, that it makes it an unusable feature. Also can’t copy anywhere but an editable text field.

    4. You are right on about email searching. what a chore it is to find that guy that sent the email about that whatchamacallit. scroll, scroll, scroll…

    5. where is the notification light? I am constantly turning on my display to see if I missed anything. this is a hardware fix, so I don’t expect anything soon.

    I think those are my core frustrations for now.

    • briansaghy says:

      As far as #3 is concerned, I’ve found it helpful to hold down the red function button, and you can scroll back and forth by just moving another finger on the touchscreen left/right without having to have needle-point accuracy. Its still about 2x as touchy as it should be. And yes, I don’t know why they don’t let me copy non-editable fields.

      For #4, you can log in to gmail’s mobile site to get search, but that doesn’t help with Exchange support. But heck, even search support within Outlook sucks.

      5 – There’s no reason they couldn’t use one of the gesture bar buttons for a notification light, so its not really a hardware fix. I’ll bet you could even hack up your Pre to do that if you really wanted to.

  4. Ron says:

    Hey, awesome on the replies! Excellent call on the gesture lights.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s